I think we can broadly say the fantasy genre relies heavily upon the European Middle Ages. When I watch The Lord of the Rings, I always imagine the departing elves as the fall of the sophisticated Roman Empire, whose empty buildings, decaying buildings, and advanced knowledge are viewed with awe and suspicion by the men left behind. But it also reminds me of something my professor told me, "The nineteenth century created our perception of the Middle Ages." In Great Britain in particular, Europeans suddenly looked back at that time in nostalgia, as was reflected in the Gothic architecture at Westminster or Sir Walter Scott's book Ivanhoe. But oftentimes they were demonstrably wrong in their depictions — our current vision of Robin Hood's men in tights are an adaptation of nineteenth century stage costume for instance — and I see it continuing into modern-day fantasy.
That's not to say it even remotely tries to claim to be historically accurate, but something very, very important is always missing from the genre. It never really struck home for me until the other day when Jennifer asked me to recommend her some books on the Middle Ages. Knowing there's literally tens of thousands out there, I tried to get her to narrow it down until finally she settled on druids. I paused for a moment before I told her druids aren't medieval history; they're Iron Age. Roman times and before. Why? Because druids ceased to exist by then. Christianity had come in.
I made that pause because I tried to figure out why on earth would she think druids and the Middle Ages had anything in common before I realized that shit is all over fantasy. How many fucking books have you read, games you've played, or movies you've watched that involved some sort of druidic ritual? And then it hit me that I can't really think of any major work, even in high fantasy, that involves Christianity. Which is insane considering how much it was intertwined with the Middle Ages. It's really hard to study anything, even pagan groups like the Vikings, without some mention of a bishop, missionary, papal policy, saint, whatever.
I'm guessing (and what I'm about to say is completely not backed with research) the fantasy genre cut out Christianity for two reasons: The first, in the English-speaking world at least, it was influenced by those earlier nineteenth-century writers, who tried to downplay the Christian aspects as much as possible to return to the Anglo-Saxon or Celtic roots. (They were kinda embarrassed Protestant Scotland and England were faithful Catholics at one point.) Second, a lot of people working in the industry today aren't religious Christians, and if they are, given the American demographics, probably not Catholic.
Again, this doesn't bother me because fantasy isn't saying it's mimicking the Middle Ages; it's an interpretation. God fucking knows there's no medieval source that lists orc "blade masters" with names like "Jubei," "Samuro," "Daisho," "Mazuru," and a flag attached to his back like he's a Japanese samurai. Or that elves were associated with bows and arrows whereas dwarves used axes. It's all make believe. But I guess it would be interesting for once to see one that tried to take in Christianity in a big way. It's hard to create a universe when something so deeply attached to our world is involved, and to be able to pull it off would be fascinating. Actually, is there? I don't read a lot of fiction, so does anyone know of one?